How to Rewrite Your Homepage Headline When Visitors Don't Get What You Do
Ask strangers what they think you sell, find the gap between their answer and the truth, then rewrite the headline to close that gap in plain words.
When visitors don't get what you do, start by finding out what they think you do. Show the headline to people who match your buyer and have never seen it, and write down their exact guesses. The gap between their guess and the truth tells you which word is missing or misleading. Rewrite to close that gap, then test again. RightMessaging shows you what simulated buyers think you're selling in minutes.
Founders usually fix a confusing headline by trying a more clever one. That swaps one guess for another. Diagnosing the confusion first tells you exactly what to change.
See what buyers think you sell with RightMessaging before you rewrite anything.
Who this is for
You've heard some version of "so what does it actually do?" from a visitor, a prospect, an investor or a friend. Maybe your demo calls start with you explaining the homepage. You suspect the headline is the problem and you want to fix it without guessing.
If you're writing a headline from scratch, the docs guide on how to write a SaaS website headline has the formula. This page is for fixing one that isn't landing.
How do you find out what visitors think you do?
Ask them, with as little help as possible.
- Show only the hero. Headline, subheadline, button. Hide the rest of the page.
- Give them a few seconds, then hide it.
- Ask two questions. "What does this product do?" and "Who is it for?"
- Write the answers down word for word. Don't correct them, and don't explain. Their wrong answer is the data.
Do this with five to ten people who match your buyer. Friends who know what you're building can't do this test, because they already know the answer.
Why visitors get it wrong, and what to change
Group the wrong answers. They usually fall into one of these patterns.
| What visitors say | Cause | What to change |
|---|---|---|
| "No idea" or a vague guess | Headline is a slogan with no category word | Add the plain category: "invoicing tool," "CRM," "scheduling app" |
| They name a different, bigger category | Your headline describes a broad benefit many tools claim | Name the specific job you do |
| They get the product, but not who it's for | No buyer named | Add the buyer in a few words |
| They describe a feature, not the outcome | Headline leads with how it works | Lead with what changes for the buyer, move the mechanism to the subheadline |
| They use your words but can't explain them | Invented terms or insider jargon | Swap each invented term for the word the buyer would use |
| Different people give very different answers | Headline covers several use cases | Pick one use case for the hero |
The last pattern usually points to positioning, so a copy tweak alone won't fix it. How to position a SaaS product with several use cases covers that fix.
How to rewrite the headline, step by step
- Write the true answer to "what does it do?" in one plain sentence, the way you'd say it to a friend at a bar. For example, "It writes your CRM notes from your sales calls."
- Compare it to the visitors' guesses. Underline the words in your sentence that none of them used. Those are the missing pieces.
- Draft three headlines that include the missing pieces. Keep the category word, the buyer and the outcome. Drop anything a stranger would need context for.
- Read each one as a stranger. Could someone who's never heard of you repeat it back correctly? Cut the ones that fail.
- Move the mechanism to the subheadline. The headline says what changes. The subheadline says how.
- Test the new versions the same way you tested the old one. You're done when most people describe the product the way you would.
A worked example
For example, say your current headline is "Revenue intelligence, reimagined."
- What testers said: "Some kind of analytics?" "A finance dashboard?" "Sales forecasting, maybe?" Nobody mentioned calls or CRM notes.
- The true sentence: "It listens to your sales calls and writes the notes into your CRM for you."
- Missing pieces: sales calls, CRM notes, the time saved, and who it's for.
- Three drafts:
- "CRM notes written from your sales calls, automatically"
- "Stop typing call notes. Your CRM fills itself after every sales call."
- "Call notes for B2B sales teams, written into your CRM before your next call"
- Retest: draft 3 gets the most correct descriptions because it names the buyer as well as the job.
Fixes that make things worse
- Making it shorter. Short is good only once it's clear. A clear 12-word headline beats a confusing 4-word one.
- Adding a second headline above the first. Two headlines split attention. Fix the one you have.
- Explaining it in a video below. A visitor confused by the hero may leave before they ever press play. A video helps people who already decided to stay.
- Copying a famous company's style. Their visitors already know what they do. Yours don't.
How to test it with RightMessaging
RightMessaging runs the stranger test for you. Paste your headline and subheadline, choose landing page as the format, and describe your ideal customer: their job, stage and the problem they're trying to solve.
Simulated buyers modelled on that customer read it, and you see their reactions: what caught their attention, what confused them and where they stopped reading. The report includes a section on what they think you're selling, which is the exact diagnostic from this guide, plus a reading funnel, what landed, what didn't, who responds best and suggested rewrites.
Run the current headline first and save the report. Then run your three drafts and compare what readers think you're selling in each. Pick the version where the answer matches your one true sentence. It's a quick first read, so confirm with a few real buyers or a small amount of traffic before you ship.
FAQ
How do I know if the headline or the rest of the page is the problem?
Run the hero-only test. If people can't say what you do from the hero, fix the headline first. If they can but still don't sign up, the problem is further down: proof, pricing or the call to action. Why your website copy isn't resonating covers those.
Should I use my product category even if I think we're different?
Yes. The category word tells visitors where to file you. Show what makes you different in the rest of the headline and the subheadline.
How many people do I need to test a headline?
Five to ten matched strangers usually make the pattern obvious, because confused answers repeat. If answers are all over the place, the headline is the problem, regardless of sample size.
Can I A/B test the headline instead?
If you have the traffic, yes, after you've fixed the obvious confusion. An A/B test tells you which version wins. It doesn't tell you what visitors think you do, so diagnose first.
Your next step
Write your one true sentence about what the product does, then run your current headline through RightMessaging and compare what buyers think you sell with that sentence. If you're rewriting for paid or outbound traffic, also read how to write a SaaS value proposition for cold traffic.