Right Suite logoRight Suite
AudienceNovember 22, 2026

How to Define Your ICP When You Sell to Several Verticals (2026)

Define one ICP by the trigger, job and constraints your buyers share, then treat each vertical as a filter on top. Pick one vertical to lead with.


When you sell to several verticals, define your ICP by what your buyers share across industries: the event that sends them looking, the job they need done and the limits they work within. Industry becomes a filter on that core, and one vertical leads your messaging. RightAudience shows which vertical responds first.

Rank your verticals in RightAudience before you write a single vertical landing page.

Who this is for

You built a horizontal product. A scheduling tool, an invoicing tool, a reporting layer, an API. Dental clinics use it. So do law firms and logistics teams. Every ICP template asks you to write "Industry: ___" and you have four answers.

This guide is for that moment. If you only sell to one industry, start with how to find your ICP with no customers instead.

Why does the standard ICP template break for multi-vertical products?

The standard template treats industry as the first and strongest filter. For a vertical product that's right. For a horizontal product it splits one real buyer into four fake ones.

The ops manager at a 40-person logistics firm and the practice manager at a 40-person dental group may have the exact same problem: too many manual handoffs, no one owns the spreadsheet, and the owner is asking why things slip. They buy for the same reason. They just use different words for it.

If you write four ICPs, you get four landing pages, four sequences and four sets of half-tested copy. None gets enough attention to work.

How to define a multi-vertical ICP, step by step

1. Write the core ICP without naming an industry

Fill in these fields using only what's true across every vertical you sell to:

FieldWhat to writeExample
TriggerThe event that makes them search nowOwner asks for a weekly report they can't produce
JobWhat they're trying to get doneGet one view of jobs in progress without chasing people
Buyer roleWho feels it and who signsOps or practice manager feels it, owner signs
Size bandHeadcount or revenue where the pain shows up20 to 150 people
Current workaroundWhat they use todayShared spreadsheet plus WhatsApp
ConstraintWhat rules options outNo IT team, needs to work in a week
DisqualifierWhat makes them a bad fitAlready on an enterprise ERP

If a field changes from vertical to vertical, it doesn't belong in the core yet. Move it to step 2.

2. Add a vertical overlay for each industry

For each vertical, write only what's different:

  • Their words for the problem. Dental says "chair time". Logistics says "dispatch". Same job, different vocabulary.
  • Where they gather. Industry associations, specific subreddits, trade newsletters.
  • Compliance or buying friction. HIPAA, procurement, insurance rules.
  • The proof they need. A logo from their own industry, or a named integration with the software they already run.

The overlay is short. If it's long, you may have two different products, and that's worth knowing early.

3. Score each vertical against the same core

Use one sheet. Score each vertical 1 to 5 on the factors that decide where you start:

FactorQuestion
Trigger frequencyHow often does the trigger happen in this vertical?
ReachabilityCan you get 50 of them on a list this week?
Budget authorityDoes the person who feels it control spend?
Proof distanceHow far is your current proof from what they need?
Sales frictionProcurement, compliance, long contracts? (5 = little friction)

The ICP scoring matrix has a fuller version if you want more rows.

4. Pick a lead vertical, keep the others on the bench

The highest score becomes your lead vertical. It gets your homepage examples, your first outbound list and your first case study. The others stay in the core ICP, so you don't turn them away, but they don't get dedicated copy until the lead vertical is converting.

5. Write the homepage for the core, the examples for the lead

Your headline speaks to the job ("See every job in progress without chasing anyone"). Your examples, screenshots and first testimonial come from the lead vertical. Visitors from other verticals still recognize the job. Visitors from the lead vertical feel it was written for them.

Symptom, check, fix

SymptomCheckFix
Homepage converts nobody in particularDoes the headline name a job or a feature?Rewrite around the shared job from step 1
One vertical replies, others don'tCompare the overlays. Is the language different?Use the replying vertical's words in that sequence only
Every vertical wants different featuresIs the job really the same?Split the ICP. You may be selling two products
Deals stall in one verticalLook at sales friction scoresBench that vertical until you have proof

Worked example

For example, say you sell a job-tracking tool at $79 a month to three verticals: dental groups, HVAC contractors and small logistics firms.

The core ICP comes out as: owner-led firm, 20 to 150 people, an ops person who chases status updates by phone, trigger is a missed job or an angry customer.

Scoring might look like this:

FactorDentalHVACLogistics
Trigger frequency354
Reachability442
Budget authority253
Proof distance233
Sales friction253
Total132215

HVAC leads. Your homepage headline stays about the job. The screenshot shows a technician dispatch board. Dental stays in the core ICP and gets a short section lower on the page, with no dedicated campaign yet.

These numbers are illustrative. Your scores come from your own list research and conversations.

How to test it with RightAudience

Scoring on your own has one weakness. You score the vertical you like higher. RightAudience gives you an outside read.

  1. Describe your offer and price once, written around the core job.
  2. Add each vertical as a segment to test, using the role and size from your core ICP ("Ops manager, HVAC contractor, 20 to 150 staff").
  3. Run it. Each segment evaluates the offer on its own.
  4. Read the ranked segment table. You get a purchase intent score per segment, the objections each one raised and a focus recommendation for where to go first.

If two verticals score close together, the report says so, and you pick the one you can reach fastest. If no vertical responds, the problem is the offer, and the barriers section tells you where to look before you change segments.

Simulated buyers give you a fast first read. Follow it with five real conversations in the lead vertical before you commit your budget.

Run your verticals through RightAudience

FAQ

Should I have a separate ICP for each vertical?

No. Keep one core ICP built on the shared trigger and job, and add a short overlay per vertical. Separate ICPs split your copy, lists and proof into pieces too small to work. Split only if the job itself differs.

How many verticals should I target at launch?

One lead vertical gets your dedicated messaging and outbound. You can still accept customers from the others, but don't build campaigns for them until the lead one converts.

What if my best customers come from a vertical I didn't plan for?

Follow them. Re-score that vertical with real data, and if it wins, make it the lead. Customers who found you without help are the strongest signal you have.

Does a multi-vertical product need a different homepage per industry?

Not at first. One homepage written around the job, with examples from your lead vertical, does the work. Add industry pages once a second vertical is converting from outreach.

Next step

Write your core ICP in the seven-field table above without naming an industry. Then rank your verticals in RightAudience and pick the one you'll lead with this month.